Beer and Immunity


Old School

The “manual model” has significant limitations around candour

Old hands used to be cynical about debriefs – a “search for the guilty, punishment of the innocent, and praise and honours for the non-participants.”


New School

“Beer and immunity” is a phrase popularized by JPMorgan Chase CEO Jamie Dimon to describe how he gathers honest feedback from frontline employees

Candid Cycle uses human experience and structured questions to understand what happened, what it means and what should change. AI strengthens a human-led inquiry rather than becoming the authority on organisational experience or capability.

The Candid Cycle structure – Context, Strengths, Improvements, Learnings and Actions already embodies the proposition. The methodology determines the questions; participants supply contextual experience; AI supports analysis across their submissions.

There are three distinct human contributions:

  1. The methodology designer establishes a useful structure for reflection. (John Salter Consulting Services via the Candid Cycle)
  2. The cycle organiser defines the event, activity, objectives and boundaries of the inquiry. (You)
  3. Participants explain (anonymously) what they experienced, including circumstances that may not appear in formal records. (Your people, or clients)


Unknown's avatar

Author: John Salter & Associates Consulting Services

John Salter - specialising in the facilitation of risk-based capability reviews; needs-based training; business continuity planning; crisis management exercises; and organisational debriefing. Recognised for “preventing disasters, or where that is not possible, reducing the potential for harm” Ref: Barrister H Selby, Inquest Handbook, 1998. Distracted by golf, camping, fishing, reading, red wine, movies and theatre.

Leave a Reply

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.