Brutally Simple

… but hopefully NOT simplistic.

The K.I.S.S. Principle (Keep It Short and Simple) reminds us to focus on the “necessary and sufficient”. An important “fit for purpose” principle which encourages focus.

The Framework used in our upcoming Capability Heatmap App

1. Develop Vision & Strategy

Criterion: Strategic objectives consistently drive actual resource allocation decisions.

Level – Description

N 🔴 Absent

Resources are allocated by history, politics, or crisis. Strategy statements exist (or not), but they have no observable effect on budgets, staffing, or priorities.

P 🟠 Ad hoc

Strategy is referenced in some decisions, but exceptions dominate. Resource shifts occur occasionally and inconsistently, often after problems emerge.

L 🔵 Defined

Most major investments and priorities are explicitly linked to strategic objectives. Trade-offs are documented and reviewed on a set cycle.

F 🟢 Operational

Capital, people, and attention are routinely reallocated as strategy evolves. Underperforming initiatives are stopped or reshaped without delay.

2. Develop & Manage Products & Services

Criterion: New or changed offerings move predictably from concept to market using a repeatable lifecycle.

Level – Description

N 🔴 Absent

Product outcomes are unpredictable. Delivery depends on individuals and luck; no common lifecycle exists.

P 🟠 Ad hoc

Some structure exists, but teams follow different approaches. Timelines, costs, and outcomes vary widely.

L 🔵 Defined

A standard lifecycle is used consistently. Time, cost, and quality outcomes are generally reliable.

F 🟢 Operational

Delivery performance is forecastable and optimised. The portfolio is actively balanced for risk, speed, and value.

3. Market & Sell Products & Services

Criterion: Demand can be forecast and influenced with reasonable accuracy.

Level – Description

N 🔴 Absent

Sales results regularly surprise the organisation. Demand is largely reactive and poorly understood.

P 🟠 Ad hoc

Forecasts exist but are frequently inaccurate or ignored. Marketing impact is unclear.

L 🔵 Defined

Demand forecasts are generally reliable and used to plan capacity, inventory, and campaigns.

F 🟢 Operational

Demand is actively shaped through pricing, channels, and targeting. Forecast accuracy is continuously improved.

4. Deliver Products & Services

Criterion: Customer commitments are met reliably without extraordinary effort.

Level – Description

N 🔴 Absent

Delivery failures are common. Success depends on heroics and last-minute intervention.

P 🟠 Ad hoc

Reliability is achieved inconsistently through manual workarounds and escalation.

L 🔵 Defined

Commitments are met consistently through defined, controlled processes.

F 🟢 Operational

Delivery is reliable, resilient, and efficient by design. Exceptions are rare and well managed.

5. Manage Customer Service

Criterion: Customer issues are resolved in a way that measurably reduces future demand for service.

Level – Description

N 🔴 Absent

Issues are handled case-by-case. No learning or prevention occurs.

P 🟠 Ad hoc

Root causes are sometimes identified, but fixes are sporadic and incomplete.

L 🔵 Defined

Systematic analysis reduces repeat issues. Service insights drive improvements upstream.

F 🟢 Operational

Demand for service is deliberately designed down. Experience, loyalty, and cost improve together.

6. Develop & Manage Human Capital

Criterion: The organisation can reliably put the right skills in the right roles when needed.

Level – Description

N 🔴 Absent

Persistent skill gaps and misaligned roles. Critical positions remain vacant or mismatched.

P 🟠 Ad hoc

Some roles are filled well, others depend on chance or individual effort.

L 🔵 Defined

Workforce planning, development, and succession reliably support business needs.

F 🟢 Operational

Skills are anticipated and repositioned ahead of demand. Capability adapts as strategy changes.

7. Manage IT & Knowledge

Criterion: Information systems and data can be depended on to support critical business decisions.

Level – Description

N 🔴 Absent

Systems and data are avoided or distrusted for important decisions.

P 🟠 Ad hoc

Core systems exist, but shadow spreadsheets and manual checks are common.

L 🔵 Defined

Data and systems are trusted for most operational and management decisions.

F 🟢 Operational

Information actively enables faster, better decisions. Data quality and insight are strategic assets.

8. Manage Financial & Physical Resources

Criterion: Capital is allocated and reallocated based on performance and expected value.

Level – Description

N 🔴 Absent

Budgets roll forward regardless of results. Capital is effectively locked in.

P 🟠 Ad hoc

Performance is reviewed, but allocations rarely change as a result.

L 🔵 Defined

Investment decisions are routinely based on value and performance evidence.

F 🟢 Operational

Capital is dynamically redeployed. Underperforming assets are corrected or exited quickly.

The Capability Heatmap app will be populated with the APQC data above, but will be flexible, allowing more, less or different elements to be edited and populated by the user to reflect context.

The “summary scorecard” showing capability maturity
Key to be used to populate the above “concept grid” and the app
Unknown's avatar

Author: John Salter & Associates Consulting Services

John Salter - specialising in the facilitation of risk-based capability reviews; needs-based training; business continuity planning; crisis management exercises; and organisational debriefing. Recognised for “preventing disasters, or where that is not possible, reducing the potential for harm” Ref: Barrister H Selby, Inquest Handbook, 1998. Distracted by golf, camping, fishing, reading, red wine, movies and theatre.

Leave a comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.